Owen Barritt (hmmm_tea) wrote,
Owen Barritt
hmmm_tea

  • Mood:
  • Music:

Drunk Driving and Responsibility

Top court set to rule today on host liability for drunk drivers

Poll #725320 Drunk Driver Liability

Should Hosts Be Responsible To Stop Their Guests Driving Drunk?

Yes
9(81.8%)
No
2(18.2%)

Should They Be Held Liable If They Fail To Do So?

Yes
1(9.1%)
No
10(90.9%)


I think you've got to have a certain degree of moral responsibility for the world around you no matter what the context and this would clearly follow through to guests. Obviously you can't physically stop someone driving drunk, but you can at least try to stop them offering them somewhere to stay for the night or to call a taxi, etc.

I don't think it should be legislated against, however, as it would certainly be difficult to judge when blame can appropriately be applied. Also, although the hosts have some responsibility for the actions of the guest, ultimate responsibility for those actions will always lie with the guest. In the case above why should the hosts be proscuted on the grounds they have insurance to cover it and the guest doesn't?

We live in a world where prosecution requires someone to always be at blame. Accidents happen, often avoidable, but that doesn't stop them happening. Why does there necessarily have to be a court prosecution to follow every one of these?
Subscribe

  • Funny the things you find gathering dust at the back of the internet

    Does this still work?  or do I need to write in cyrillic to post on here nowadays?

  • Apropos Nothing

    Did they do something to the comments form? I'm sure it didn't look like that this morning... Also, oh look, first post of the year. Happy New Year!…

  • 2011

    Judging by twitter it looked something like this: January 1/1 is beginning to wonder if there are any marching bands left in America or…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 7 comments